KASU

Hamas Conflict Could Have Lingering Impact On Israel's Economy

Aug 18, 2014
Originally published on August 18, 2014 9:51 am

Itay Maoz climbs into his dusty SUV and presses a series of buttons on his cellphone, which opens an electronic gate surrounding the Nahal Oz Kibbutz. From here, in the far south of Israel, you can see across the border into Gaza and the remains of buildings pulverized by Israeli missiles.

This 2,500-acre collective farm was on the front line during the war between Israel and Hamas, and it sustained millions of dollars worth of damage. Maoz points at a patch of hard earth, gouged with deep tracks, leading toward Gaza.

"That used to be a road," Maoz says. "Not anymore." He says all the military tanks were crossing here, so there's nothing left of the road.

Maoz says Israeli tanks and soldiers swarmed this area once the fighting with Hamas began. The tanks flattened the fields, destroying everything in their path, including the kibbutz's sophisticated irrigation system, turning the area into a large dust bowl.

Residents were ordered not to go into the fields, and Maoz says hundreds of acres of cabbages, wheat, melons and more were destroyed. He says the fruit in a nearby watermelon field should be green and blooming right now, but after six weeks without water, the watermelons are very small and rotting.

"That's a total loss of the field — nothing we can do with this field," Maoz says.

He says the crop next year, and probably the year after, will also be affected. Maoz estimates the cost to be 6 to 7 million shekels, about $2 million U.S., and has appealed for government help. He says the kibbutz was adequately compensated after other wars with Hamas, but this one went on much longer.

Analysts say the war could cost the Israeli economy about $3 billion, if you include things like lost wages. Businesses, especially those in the south, suffered as customers stayed in their homes.

In the nearby city of Ashkelon, often a target of rocket fire from Gaza, the shopping malls were empty throughout much of the conflict. At an Office Depot shop, deputy manager Elena Smolanov says the parking lot was empty day after day.

"People didn't leave their home, they were scared," she says. "We were sitting here, basically five employees each shift, and just basically looking at each other." Smolanov says customers are starting to trickle back, especially with the start of a new school year.

One of the hardest-hit sectors was tourism. The number of foreign tourists arriving plummeted more than 25 percent. The Israeli government was outraged when the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration suspended American flights to Israel after a rocket landed near Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion airport. Some Asian and European airlines continue to stay away.

A new radio and TV campaign is trying to reverse the decline in tourism locally and from overseas. While Israeli spokesmen highlighted the rocket threat during the war, tourism minister Uzi Landau is now stressing a different view.

"In fact, the true story in the country is different," Landau says. "When you come to the place, you do see in all of our cities, apart of those areas which are close to Gaza, lines go on almost as if it were routine."

Yacov Sheinin, director of the consultancy firm Economic Models, says Israel's economy, which has been averaging more than 3 percent growth per year, will rebound from this, as it has after other conflicts. He says robust sectors, like high tech, will continue to attract foreign investors.

"If they're coming to high tech, they will come, they're coming," Sheinin says. "[But] not as much as we could get if there would be peace." Sheinin says foreign investors will come because they know about the cost and the risk.

The one area that will see perhaps the largest growth is defense. Israel's defense ministry is asking for a more than $3 billion hike for next year, something Israel's finance ministry calls "excessive."

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

All right. Alice was just talking there about how this month-long conflict has destroyed hundreds of homes and factories in Gaza, affecting the livelihoods of thousands of Palestinians. Israelis are also tallying up the cost of the fight against Hamas, which has gone on much longer than previous conflicts with the militant group. NPR's Jackie Northam reports.

JACKIE NORTHAM, BYLINE: Itay Maoz climbs into his dusty SUV and presses a series of buttons on his cell phone, which opens an electronic gate surrounding the Nahal Oz Kibbutz. From here, in the far south of Israel, you can see across the border into Gaza at the remains of buildings pulverized by Israel missiles. This 2,500 acre collective farm was on the front line during the war between Israel and Hamas.

ITAY MAOZ: Gaza is straight there - that used to be a road. Not anymore.

NORTHAM: What happened to it?

MAOZ: All the tanks were crossing here so, nothing left from that.

NORTHAM: Israeli tanks and soldiers swarmed this area once the fighting with Hamas began. The tanks flattened the fields, destroyed the roads and sophisticated irrigation system and turned the area into a large dust bowl. Residents were ordered not to go into the fields. Maoz says, hundreds of acres of cabbages, wheat, melons and more were destroyed.

MAOZ: So what we can see here, it's a watermelon field; it's supposed to be green and blooming right now. But, after six weeks without water it looks like this.

NORTHAM: They're very small and they look like they're rotting right now, don't they?

MAOZ: Yeah, absolutely. That's a total loss of the field.

NORTHAM: Maoz says, next year's crop and probably the year after will also be affected. He estimates the cost to be between 6 and 7 million shekels; about $2 million and has appealed for government help. He says the Kibbutz was adequately compensated after other wars with Hamas but this one went on much longer.

Analysts say the war could cost the Israeli economy about $3 billion, if you include things like lost wages. Businesses, especially in the South, suffered as customers stayed in their homes.

At this Office Depot, in the city of Ashkelon, customers are starting to trickle back, especially with the start of a new school year. That's a relief for deputy manager Elena Smolanov.

ELENA SMOLANOV: (Through translator) People didn't leave the home, they were scared. So we were sitting here, basically five employees each shift and just basically looking at each other.

NORTHAM: One of the hardest hit sectors was tourism. The number of foreign tourists arriving plummeted, by more than 25 percent. The Israeli government was outraged when the U.S. Federal Aviation Administration suspended American flights to Israel after a rocket landed near Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion airport. Some Asian and European airlines continue to stay away.

NORTHAM: A new radio and TV campaign is trying to reverse the decline in tourism, locally and from overseas. While Israeli spokesmen highlighted the rocket threat during the war, now Uzi Landau, the tourism minister, is stressing a different view.

UZI LANDAU: In fact, the true story in the country is different because when you come to the place, you do see that in all of our cities, apart of those areas which are close to Gaza, lines go on almost as if it were routine.

NORTHAM: Yacov Sheinin, director of the consultancy firm Economic Models, says Israel's economy, which has been averaging more than 3 percent growth per year, will rebound from this, as it has after other conflicts. He says robust sectors like high tech will continue to attract foreign investors.

YACOV SHEININ: So foreign investment, if you're coming to high-tech, they will come. Not as much as we could get if there would be peace, but they're coming because they know what is the cost and what's the risk - and they'll come.

NORTHAM: The one area that will see perhaps the largest growth is defense. Israel's defense ministry is asking for a more than $3 billion hike for next year. Something Israel's finance ministry calls excessive.

Jackie Northam. NPR News, Jerusalem. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.